Movie Time Movies - Forgetting Sarah Marshall
Thursday, April 24th, 2008

A few months back I wrote about Knocked Up and how it was actually a chick flick in disguise, or a reverse chick flick. They set you up with some dick and fart jokes, the regular guy gets the chick, then totally trashes his life for this chick who is really just a bitch that he happened to impregnate, which eventually is what makes him happy all along. I felt betrayed and hurt that the man who brought us Anchorman was fucking us over with a movie that basically said that the only way to find happiness was to sell out completely. It made me want to run around in the summer sun and drink milk.
So, with great trepidation, I decided to check out Forgetting Sarah Marshall, the latest movie from the Judd Apatow camp. The ads showed a forlorn guy (Jason Segel from How I Met Your Mother fame) trying to get over his hot ass (but kind of cross-eyed) tv actress ex-girlfriend (Kristen Bell aka Veronica Mars) by going to a Hawaiian resort where he just so happens to run into his ex who is there with her new rock star boyfriend Aldous Snow (played to narcissistic perfection by Russell Brand, some British dude I never heard of). There was certainly a lot of potential for reverse chick flick action.
Now don’t get me wrong, I enjoyed Knocked Up, but the whole reverse chick flick thing left me kind of hand-shy. I didn’t want to get smacked and scolded about how I’d never find happiness until I gave up everything I loved to make some ho happy. But I had read some things online, and the buzz was convincing enough that I decided to go see it. I was not disappointed.
Forgetting Sarah Marshall (which in my head I’ve called Forgetting Sara Silverman about a hundred times) is a date movie for sure, but it’s not a chick flick. Sure Peter Bretter, a slacker musician that happens to score the fake CSI knock-off that his girlfriend Sarah Marshall stars in, is lazy and goofy, but he’s a good guy. Where Knocked Up made Seth Rogen look like a stoner loser that couldn’t get his life together, this movie shows Peter as a guy that knows where he wants to be, but is tied down by stability: an easy paycheck, a stable, long-term relationship, a comfortable couch. As the movie progresses, a couple of flashback sequences show how Peter was a pretty great boyfriend that happened to suffer from the occasional bout of laziness. Another flashback sequence showed how Sarah really wasn’t all that great. Besides being hot and all, she was mostly a very selfish girlfriend who got worse the more famous she got. Did you see what they did there? They made the guy look good and the girl look bad! What can I say? I like my movies fair and balanced, just like my news.
Back to the plot, after the break-up and a string of unfulfilling one night stands (the best kind of one night stands, really), he jets off to Hawaii to a resort that Sarah always talked about. Well, wouldn’t you know, she’s there on vacation, too! Awkward… Fortunately for Peter he gets bailed out by the exotically hot, yet unappealingly tan, front-desk clerk Rachel (Mila Kunis).
He spends the first part of his vacation wallowing in misery and alcohol. Then he mans up and asks out Rachel, who is a low maintenance free spirit that appears to be hiding out from real life in Hawaii. Rachel takes Peter out for a good time, even coaxing him to do a song from his work-in-progress Dracula rock opera at a local bar.
As Rachel and Peter get closer Sarah realizes that her great new relationship with Aldous isn’t all she hoped for. He’s incredibly shallow and self-centered and doesn’t cater to her like Peter did. Sure, he fucks like Superman, but she starts to pine for Peter, particularly when she notices the burgeoning relationship between him and Rachel.
The rest of the plot you can probably figure out for yourself. Even though it’s a little on the predictable side, the story manages to keep you entertained with the little twists and turns that flesh out the rest of the story.
I’d say the strongest part of the movie is the supporting cast. Apatow regulars like Jonah Hill, Paul Rudd, Bill Hader, and even the girl that put the period blood on Jonah Hill’s leg in Superbad are all here. The resort workers are a riot, with the South Central LA refugee bartender who wants to take Peter snorkeling because it’s “sea turtle fucking season and they get it on for three hours,” and the gigantic but sweet chef that puts the whipped cream or berries on your waffles.
But let’s not forget the newlywed that is deathly afraid of his new wife’s insatiable sex drive played by Jack McBrayer (30 Rock’s Kenneth). I fucking love that guy. The way he always plays the innocent makes me really wonder what he’s like. I like to picture him as a black metal listening sex fiend that spikes his YooHoo with absinthe. He’s a scene-stealer, for sure.
Another interesting aspect of the movie is the relative nonchalance of the sexual matter in the movie. None of the love scenes seem exceptionally lascivious, but they seem very matter of fact and true to life, besides the acrobatic first scene with Sarah and Aldous, which is just ridiculous. The movie even manages to make a blowjob not look totally filthy, which is a rarity in the movies. Something that was once very taboo and solely the realm of sluts and hookers in movies is used in a very commonplace way, much as it is used in peoples’ regular sex lives.
I definitely recommend seeing this movie. It’s a genuinely funny movie with a heart. It’s not the greatest movie of all time or anything, but it’s nice to see that someone made a date movie that’s not a chick flick. But don’t think that they forgot you, ladies. You see Segel’s dong something like three times. Yep, full frontal dongage. Fellas, you’ve been warned.

